Types of Multiple Sclerosis
|
|
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic, progressive disease that leads to increasing
disability in most individuals. Descriptions of the disease have always included two
types of clinical processes, an acute process involving relapses
and a chronically persistent progressive process, for which the
underlying pathogenic mechanisms of onset are unknown.
The vast majority of individuals present with the acute relapsing-remitting form
of the disease, and the treatments that are currently available to treat MS are
most effective for these individuals. For the majority of those patients who eventually
transition to secondary-progressive MS (SPMS) and for those whose disease course is
progressive from onset, primary-progressive MS (PPMS), treatment options at this time
primarily involve symptomatic management and rehabilitation to mitigate the impact
of the disease progression.
In spite of the apparent differences in clinical manifestation between the disease
courses, the consensus has been that these differences are more quantitative than
qualitative and that the relapsing and progressive courses of MS fall along a disease
spectrum, with genetic and environmental factors contributing to the variations. While
continuing to examine the apparent similarities and differences between the MS disease
courses, the international MS community has come together to expedite the development
of effective disease-modifying and symptom management therapies for progressive
forms of MS.
The International Progressive MS Collaborative has identified the following five
research priorities: experimental models for progressive MS; identification and
validation of treatment targets and repurposing opportunities; proof-of-concept
clinical trial strategies; clinical outcome measures; and symptom management and
rehabilitation strategies.
|
The Four Main Types of MS
|
|
In 1996, the International
Advisory Committee on Clinical Trials of MS originally identified four disease courses
MS. The original four disease courses (types) of MS in 1996 were:
● |
Relapsing-Remitting MS |
● |
Primary-Progressive MS |
● |
Secondary-Progressive MS |
● |
Progressive-Relapsing MS |
These four provided purely clinical types based on data and consensus at that time, but
time has shown that imaging and biological correlates were lacking. Increased understanding
of MS and its pathology, coupled with general concern that the original descriptors may
not adequately reflect more recently identified clinical aspects of the disease, prompted
a re-examination of MS disease types.
The changes that were adopted in 2013 by the committee: they retained three of the disease
course descriptions first developed in 1996, they included the addition of clinically isolated
syndrome (CIS), and they eliminated progressive-relapsing MS (PRMS). In addition, modifiers
have been added to promote more effective conversations about disease activity and progression
and shared decision-making about treatment options. The modifiers, such as "active" and "not
active," incorporate information from MRIs, relapses and degree of disability.
Accordingly, the new classifications also provides guidelines for how often MRIs should be
used to assess someone's MS. Under the old criteria, doctors waited until someone had another
event with more clinical findings and more disability. The newer criteria include utilizing MRI
with gadolinium (a contrast agent) to help make a diagnosis sooner and to recognize changes in
established MS so that treatment changes can be considered.
You may see differences in the way the MS disease courses (also called "types" or
"phenotypes") are defined here on our website and in our other resources including
print publications. This discrepancy is due to others not knowing about, not yet
updating, or not wanting to adapt to the new standard. The revised courses, as discussed above,
were updated from the descriptions first published in 1996 and developed by the
International Advisory Committee on Clinical Trials of MS in 2013
, based on advances in the understanding of the disease process in MS and in MRI
technology.
The current four disease courses (types) of MS (New as of 2013):
● |
Clinically Isolated Syndrome (CIS) |
|
● |
Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS) |
|
● |
Secondary-Progressive Multiple Sclerosis (SPMS) |
|
● |
Primary-Progressive Multiple Sclerosis (PPMS) |
|
The 1996 vs 2013 MS Phenotype Descriptions for Relapsing Disease
Enlarge by passing over or clicking
Relapsing Disease Images Above: *Activity determined by clinical relapses and/or MRI activity (contrast-enhancing
lesions; new or unequivocally enlarging T2 lesions assessed at least annually); if assessments
are not available, activity is "indeterminate." **CIS, if subsequently clinically active and
fulfilling current MS diagnostic criteria, becomes relapsing-remitting MS (RRMS).
The 1996 vs 2013 MS Phenotype Descriptions for Progressive Disease
Enlarge by passing over or clicking
Progressive Disease Images Above: *Activity determined by clinical relapses assessed at
least annually and/or MRI activity (contrast-enhancing lesions; new and unequivocally
enlarging T2 lesions). **Progression measured by clinical evaluation, assessed at least
annually. If assessments are not available, activity and progression are "indeterminate."
MS = multiple sclerosis; PP = primary-progressive; PR = progressive-relapsing;
SP = secondary-progressive.
Clinically Isolated Syndrome (CIS)
Clinically isolated syndrome (CIS) was not included in the initial MS clinical descriptors.
CIS is now recognized as the first clinical presentation of a disease that shows
characteristics of inflammatory demyelination that could be MS, but has yet to fulfill
criteria of dissemination in time. Natural history studies and clinical trials of MS
disease-modifying therapies (DMTs) have shown that CIS coupled with brain MRI lesions
carries a high risk for meeting diagnostic criteria for MS. Clinical trials of MS DMTs
show fewer treated individuals with CIS who develop a second exacerbation (the defining
event for "clinically definite MS") and reduced MRI activity.
With neurologic symptoms caused by inflammation and demyelination in the central nervous
system (CNS), this first episode — which must last at least 24 hours, according to definition —
is typical of MS but does not yet meet the criteria for a diagnosis of the disease. Sometimes,
people who have a CIS will not go on to develop MS. An MRI will better determine the
likelihood that someone who has a CIS will develop MS. If lesions on a brain MRI are
seen with a CIS, there is a higher chance the patient will develop MS.
This will provide a more detailed sub-class will give two types of CIS:
● |
CIS Not Active |
● |
CIS Active |
The new classification provides a way, using these newer diagnostic criteria, to diagnose
and treat a person as having MS with the first clinical event, if they have certain findings
on their MRI. Correspondingly, individuals who have experienced CIS and who are considered at
high risk of developing full-blown MS (that is, their CIS is accompanied by MS-like lesions
seen on MRI) may now be treated with a DMT.
For More Detail:
Clinically isolated syndrome (CIS) is one of the MS disease courses. CIS refers
to a first episode of neurologic symptoms that lasts at least 24 hours and is
caused by inflammation or demyelination (loss of the myelin that covers the nerve
cells) in the central nervous system (CNS). CIS can be either monofocal or multifocal.
With CIS, an MRI may demonstrate damage only in the area responsible for the current
symptoms; with MS, there may be multiple lesions on MRI in different areas of the brain.
A person with CIS, by definition, is experiencing the first episode of symptoms caused
by inflammation and demyelination in the CNS; a person with MS has experienced more than
one episode.
Monofocal episode -
The person experiences a single neurologic sign or symptom. For
example, an attack of optic neuritis — that’s caused by a single
lesion.
Multifocal episode -
The person experiences more than one sign or symptom. For
example, an attack of optic neuritis accompanied by weakness on
one side — caused by lesions in more than one place.
|
The episode usually has no associated fever or infection and is followed by a complete
or partial recovery.
CIS Progression To MS
Individuals who experience CIS may or may not go on to develop MS. In diagnosing
CIS, the healthcare provider faces two challenges: first, to determine whether the
person is experiencing a neurologic episode caused by damage in the CNS; and second,
to determine the likelihood that a person experiencing this type of demyelinating
event is going to go on to develop MS.
High risk of developing MS: -
When CIS is accompanied by MRI-detected brain
lesions that are similar to those seen in MS, the person has a 60 to 80%
chance of a second neurologic event and diagnosis of MS within several years.
Low risk of developing MS: -
When CIS is not accompanied by MRI-detected brain lesions, the person has
about a 20% chance of developing MS over the same period of time.
|
According to the 2010 revisions to the diagnostic criteria for MS, the diagnosis of MS
can be made when CIS is accompanied by MRI findings (old lesions or scars) that confirm
that an earlier episode of damage occurred in a different location in the CNS. As MRI
technology becomes more advanced, it's likely that the diagnosis of MS will be made
more quickly and there will be fewer people diagnosed with CIS.
An accurate diagnosis at this time is important because people with a high risk of
developing MS are encouraged to begin treatment with a disease-modifying therapy in
order to delay or prevent a second neurologic episode and, therefore, the onset of
MS. In addition, early treatment may minimize future disability caused by further
inflammation and damage to nerve cells, which are sometimes silent (occurring without
any noticeable symptoms). Several medications are now approved by the U.S. Food and
Drug Administration (FDA) for CIS: Avonex®, Betaseron®, Copaxone®, Extavia®, Glatopa™.
Like MS, CIS is two to three times more common in women than men. 70% of people
diagnosed with CIS are between the ages of 20 and 40 years (average 30 years) but
people can develop CIS at older or younger ages. Based upon clinical symptoms alone,
CIS and MS may appear the same. In both, damage to the myelin sheath (demyelination)
interferes with the way nerve impulses are carried from the brain, resulting in
neurologic symptoms.
According to the 2010 revisions to the diagnostic criteria for MS, when CIS is accompanied
by specific findings on MRI that demonstrate that another episode has occurred in the past,
the diagnosis of MS can be made.
Many episodes of CIS are mild and resolve without treatment. In other cases, treatment with
high dose oral or intravenous methylprednisolone (a steroid) is typically recommended. An MS
disease-modifying therapy is often recommended for people diagnosed with a CIS that is
considered more likely to progress to clinically definite MS (CDMS), with the goal of
delaying a second attack.
Several large-scale clinical trials have been conducted to determine whether early treatment
following a CIS can delay the second clinical event, and therefore the diagnosis of CDMS.
Based on the results of these studies, the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has
expanded the indication of several medications used to treat MS to include individuals who
have experienced a first clinical episode and have MRI findings consistent with MS. The
results of these trials, and the FDA's approval of expanded labeling for certain medications
used to treat MS, support the earliest possible treatment for MS, which many believe may
delay the development of permanent clinical disabilities.
At this time, it is difficult to predict the future course a person who is diagnosed with
a CIS will experience.
Relapsing-Remitting Multiple Sclerosis (RRMS)
This is the most common form of MS with clear defined phases of relapse (repeat attacks or
exacerbations), with progressive worsening of nerve functions with each attack, followed by
phases of relief (or remission) where normal conditions are restored partially or completely.
During remission, all symptoms may disappear, or some symptoms may continue and become
permanent. However, there is no apparent progression of the disease during the periods of
remission.
A more detailed sub-class will give four types of RRMS: Active Not Worsening, Active Worsening, Not
Active Not Worsening, and Not Active Worsening. At different points in time, RRMS can be further
characterized as either active (with relapses and/or evidence of new
MRI activity) or not active, as well as
worsening (a confirmed increase in disability over a specified period of time following
a relapse) or not worsening.
Previously, those diagnosed with PPMS were not considered eligible for treatment with a
disease-modifying therapy (DMT). However, under the new descriptions, people with active PPMS
(those who have new inflammation or a new relapse) may talk with their doctors about possible
treatment with a DMT.
This will provide a more detailed sub-class will give four types of RRMS:
● |
RRMS Active Worsening |
● |
RRMS Active Not Worsening |
● |
RRMS Not Active Worsening |
● |
RRMS Not Active Not Worsening |
Approximately 85% of people with MS are initially diagnosed with RRMS.
For More Detail:
Relapsing-remitting is the most common disease course of MS, characterized by clearly
defined attacks of new or increasing neurologic symptoms. These attacks, also called
relapses or exacerbations, are followed by periods of partial or complete recovery
(remissions). During remissions, all symptoms may disappear, or some symptoms may
continue and become permanent. However, there is no apparent progression of the
disease during the periods of remission.
At different points in time, RRMS can be further characterized as either active (with
relapses and/or evidence of new MRI activity) or not active, as well as worsening (a
confirmed increase in disability over a specified period of time following a relapse)
or not worsening. An increase in disability is confirmed when the person exhibits the
same level of disability at the next scheduled neurological evaluation, typically 6
to 12 months later.
Following a relapse, the new symptoms may disappear without causing any increase in
level of disability, or the new symptoms may only partially disappear, resulting in
an increase in disability. New lesions on MRI, as shown by the arrows, often occur
as part of a relapse. However, new MRI lesions indicating MS activity may also occur
without symptoms of which the person is aware.
RRMS is defined by inflammatory attacks on myelin (the layers of insulating membranes
surrounding nerve fibers in the CNS), as well as the nerve fibers themselves. During
these inflammatory attacks, activated immune cells cause small, localized areas of
damage which produce the symptoms of MS. Because the location of the damage is so
variable, no two people have exactly the same symptoms.
Why are modifiers used to characterize RRMS?
Disease activity and progression should be evaluated at regular intervals by neurologic
examination and MRI. Being able to characterize the course of your disease at different
points in time helps you and your MS care provider discuss your treatment options and
expected outcomes. For example:
● |
If you have RRMS that is active and worsening, you and your
MS care provider will likely want to consider a more aggressive treatment
approach than if there were no evidence of activity or worsening. Together,
you can weigh the potential risks and benefits of other treatment options. |
● |
If your symptoms have not worsened on the treatment you are
currently taking, but you have evidence of new disease activity on your
MRI, you and your healthcare provider may discuss switching to another
treatment with a different mechanism of action in order to control the
disease activity more effectively and help prevent worsening. |
● |
If your RRMS is stable without evidence of MRI activity or
worsening, you and your doctor can feel confident that the current treatment
regimen is working effectively. |
How does RRMS differ from progressive types of MS?
While RRMS is defined by attacks of inflammation (relapses) in the CNS, progressive forms
of MS involve much less of this type of inflammation.
● |
People with RRMS tend to have more brain lesions, also
called plaques or scars, on MRI scans, and these lesions contain more
inflammatory cells. |
● |
People with primary progressive MS (PPMS) tend to have
more spinal cord lesions, which contain fewer inflammatory cells. |
In RRMS, women are affected two to three times as often as men; in PPMS, the number of
women and men are approximately equal.
RRMS is diagnosed earlier than the progressive disease courses:
● |
Most people with RRMS are diagnosed in their 20s and 30s
(although it can occur in childhood or later adulthood), while the onset
of PPMS tends to be in ones 40s or 50s. |
● |
The transition to SPMS generally occurs in people who have
been living with RRMS for at least 10 years. |
The most common symptoms reported in RRMS include episodic bouts of fatigue, numbness,
vision problems, spasticity or stiffness, bowel and bladder problems, and problems with
cognition (learning and memory or information processing). People with progressive forms
of MS are more likely to experience gradually worsening problems with walking and mobility,
along with whatever other symptoms they may have.
Secondary-Progressive Multiple Sclerosis (SPMS)
Secondary-progressive follows an initial relapsing-remitting course, with continued
relapses and progressive neurological damage. Most patients will eventually transition
to a secondary-progressive course, in which there is a progressive worsening of neurologic
function (accumulation of disability) over time, with or without remissions. SPMS can be further
characterized at different points in time as either active
(with relapses and/or evidence of new MRI activity) or not active,
as well as with progression (evidence of disease worsening on an
objective measure of change over time, with or without relapses) or
without progression. Disability gradually increases over time during this course.
This will provide a more detailed sub-class will give four types of SPMS:
● |
SPMS Active with Progression |
● |
SPMS Active without Progression |
● |
SPMS Not Active with Progression |
● |
SPMS Not Active without Progression |
In most clinical contexts, SPMS is diagnosed retrospectively by a history of gradual
worsening after an initial relapsing disease course, with or without acute exacerbations
during the progressive course. To date, there are no clear clinical, imaging, immunologic,
or pathologic criteria to determine the transition point when RRMS converts to SPMS; the
transition is usually gradual. This has limited the ability to study the imaging and
biomarker characteristics that may distinguish this course.
For More Detail:
SPMS follows an initial relapsing-remitting course. Most people who are diagnosed with
RRMS will eventually transition to a secondary-progressive course in which there is a
progressive worsening of neurologic function (accumulation of disability) over time.
SPMS can be further characterized at different points in time as either active (with
relapses and/or evidence of new MRI activity) or not active, as well as with progression
(evidence of disease worsening on an objective measure of change over time, with or
without relapses) or without progression.
Following a period of relapsing-remitting disease, disability gradually increases over
time, with or without evidence of disease activity (relapses or changes on MRI). In
SPMS, occasional relapses may occur, as well as periods of stability.
Why are modifiers used to characterize SPMS?
Disease activity and progression should be evaluated at least yearly by neurologic
examination and MRI. Being able to characterize the course of your disease at different
points in time helps you and your MS care provider discuss your treatment options and
expected outcomes. For example:
● |
If you have SPMS that is active, you and your MS care
provider will want to talk about treatment with a DMT to reduce the
risk of a relapse. |
● |
If you have SPMS that is active and progressing in spite
of the medication you are taking, the conversation with your MS care
provider might be about the potential benefits and risks associated
with switching to a more aggressive treatment strategy. |
● |
If your SPMS is not active but there is evidence of
progression and accumulation of disability, you and your MS care
provider will want to focus on rehabilitation strategies to help
improve your function and mobility, and promote safety and independence. |
● |
If your SPMS is stable without activity or progression,
the conversation with your MS care could focus on rehabilitation and
other symptom management strategies to help you maintain function. |
How does SPMS differ from the other disease courses?
SPMS occurs in people who initially had a relapsing-remitting disease course. In
other words, SPMS occurs as a second phase of the disease for many individuals.
Primary-progressive MS (PPMS) is the first — and only — phase of the illness for
approximately 15% of people with MS.
In SPMS, people may or may not continue to experience relapses caused by inflammation;
the disease gradually changes from the inflammatory process seen in RRMS to a more
steadily progressive phase characterized by nerve damage or loss.
The DMTs may be effective for people with SPMS who experience relapses.
Primary-Progressive Multiple Sclerosis (PPMS)
PPMS is characterized by worsening neurologic function (accumulation of disability) from
the onset of symptoms, without early relapses or remissions. PPMS can be further characterized
at different points in time as either active (with an occasional
relapse and/or evidence of new MRI activity) or not active, as
well as with progression (evidence of disease worsening on an
objective measure of change over time, with or without relapse or new MRI activity) or
without progression.
This will provide a more detailed sub-class will give four types of PPMS:
● |
PPMS Active with Progression |
● |
PPMS Active without Progression |
● |
PPMS Not Active with Progression |
● |
PPMS Not Active without Progression |
While some evidence suggests that PPMS represents a distinct, noninflammatory or at least
less inflammatory pathologic form of MS, abundant clinical, imaging, and genetic data
suggest that PPMS is a part of the spectrum of progressive MS phenotypes and that any
differences are relative rather than absolute. Analyses of natural history cohorts
demonstrate that worsening proceeds at a similar rate in SPMS and PPMS. PPMS remains a
separate clinical course because of the absence of exacerbations prior to clinical
progression, but it likely doesn't have pathophysiologically distinct features from
relapsing forms of MS that have entered a progressive course (SPMS).
Approximately 15% of people with MS are diagnosed with PPMS.
For More Detail:
PPMS is characterized by worsening neurologic function (accumulation of disability) from
the onset of symptoms, without early relapses or remissions. PPMS can be further characterized
at different points in time as either active (with an occasional relapse and/or evidence of
new MRI activity) or not active, as well as with progression (evidence of disease worsening
on an objective measure of change over time, with or without relapse or new MRI activity) or
without progression.
PPMS can have brief periods when the disease is stable, with or without a relapse or new MRI
activity, as well as periods when increasing disability occurs with or without new relapses
or lesions on MRI.
Why are modifiers used to characterize PPMS?
Disease activity and progression should be evaluated at least yearly by neurologic
examination and MRI. Being able to characterize the course of your disease course
at different points in time helps you and your MS care provider have important
conversations about your treatment options and prognosis. For example:
● |
If you have PPMS that is active, with new MRI activity or
relapses, your conversation with your MS care provider could be about
starting treatment with a disease-modifying therapy to reduce the risk
of a relapse, as well as rehabilitation to help improve function and
mobility. |
● |
If you have PPMS that is stable without activity or progression,
the conversation with your MS care provider should include the role of
rehabilitation to help you maintain function, as well as other symptom
management strategies that you may need. |
● |
If you have PPMS that is not active (no new MRI activity or
relapses) but is progressing with increasing accumulation of disability,
the conversation with your MS provider needs to focus on the rehabilitation
strategies that can help you maintain function and keep you safe and
independently mobile. |
How does PPMS differ from the other disease courses?
Although there is a lot of variability among people with PPMS, we know that as
a group, they differ in several ways from people with relapsing forms of MS:
● |
Relapsing forms of MS (including relapsing-remitting and
secondary progressive in those individuals who continue to experience
relapses) are defined by inflammatory attacks on myelin. PPMS involves
much less inflammation of the type seen in relapsing MS. As a result,
people with PPMS tend to have fewer brain lesions (also called plaques)
than people with relapsing MS and the lesions tend to contain fewer
inflammatory cells. People with PPMS also tend to have more lesions in
the spinal cord than in the brain. Together, these differences make PPMS
more difficult to diagnose and treat than relapsing forms of MS. |
● |
In the relapsing forms, women are affected two to three times
as often as men; in PPMS, the numbers of women and men are approximately equal. |
● |
The average age of onset is approximately 10 years later in
PPMS than in relapsing MS. |
● |
People with PPMS tend to experience more problems with walking
and more difficulty remaining in the workforce. |
● |
In general, people with PPMS may also require more assistance
with their everyday activities. |
New Multiple Sclerosis Types - After 2013
Enlarge by passing over or clicking
Multiple Sclerosis Types - Prior to 2013
Enlarge by passing over or clicking
|
|
|